It’s not that this is a bad short, but it’s a one note joke, which is unusual for Disney. Yes, the lead characters are three blind mice who dress up like the Three Musketeers. As you would imagine, their blindness makes it difficult for them to do typical Musketeer things like swordfight, fight villains and the like.
So, the joke of the short becomes the way that the mice escape from constant danger, despite their blindness. The captain, played by a cat version of Pete, sets up traps for the mice, to no avail. We get an early example of how the short will go when the mice step out of their hole, looking for cheese, and the cat has set up an ax to swing back and forth in front of the hole. Oblivious to the ax, the mice stumble out of the hole and luckily avoid the ax.
The same joke happens again when the mice find the cheese. Although the cat has set out elaborate traps for them, the mice somehow manage to blunder through and not get killed by the knives or bear traps. The ax gag was funny, but to repeat it was not as funny. Unfortunately, it doesn’t stop there.
When the mice sneak away with the food, the cat sleeps. The mice carve up the cheese and sausages and more, ultimately waking up their adversary. But instead of a straight up fight or elaborate trickery, the mice have to engage in some blind gags to get away. The best gag in the short, though, is when the mice are delivering their “All for one, and one for all” line, but when the cat comes near, they scream, “Every man for himself!” I laughed a lot at that one.
But after that, it’s just…uninspired. It’s interesting to see the cat play a shell game with one of the mice underneath a series of bowls, but it’s not particularly funny or clever. Same thing with the end of the short, when the cat runs away from the mice because he sees one of them cheering into a collection of bottles, and thinks the reflection in the bottles is an army of mice coming after him.
I think the problem is that the whole thing feels like a simple joke taken too far. It’s not entertaining for 8+ minutes to see these blind mice stumbling about. It could actually be offensive if you have thin skin. Not one of the better efforts in the Silly Symphonies.
All images copyright Disney. All rights reserved.
Since this is from before the era of “political correctness,” I’m not too surprised that they don’t show sensitivity towards the feelings of the community of the blind.
ReplyDeleteI also don’t see any lack of artistry in this short. The drawing, color, and animation are quite good.
It’s also unusual to say that the story is especially lacking here, since it seems to me, after re-reading the last few reviews, that the Disney studio in general is a bit lacking on the writing side of things.
-Brian
This is the Silly Symphony that every one hates – just check out the comments this short has received on Patrick's site. So I'm almost embarrassed to admit I really, really like this one. I like the music and the simple story. I like the rhythmic, repeating actions of the characters and I enjoy all the traps and the way the mice obliviously overcome them.
ReplyDeleteSo there, I've confessed to liking this cartoon! Now let's move onto some stuff that shows how Disney is moving forward (even if you feel in other ways this cartoon is a step backward). This is one of the best-looing cartoons to date and, from a tecnhical standpoint, it seems no expense has been spared. Oddly the presentation of this cartoon on the DVD isn't the best in terms of colour (it somehow seems a little bright and faded), and I've seen it look better elsewhere. Still the colours are rich, there's some atmospheric lighting and shadows and some very clever visual stuff.
The backgrounds are highly detailed and the Disney artists do everything they can to make the viewer believe the characters are really inside this world. At one point the smallest mouse even goes 'inside' part of the painted backgrounds when he enters a green glass teapot. This kind of thing really adds dimension to the painted world in which the characters live. Captain Katt's lantern really glows – an effect quite like this I don't think we've seen before. There's also some great atmospheric stuff, like when the axe swings past the mouse hole, blocking out all the light on the other side, darkening the whole scene.
A lot of sophisticated stuff is done with shadows and lighting in this one, even more so than before. The backgrounds are beautiful and I don't even know how some of the visual effects were achieved (I suspect filters were used some how). Aesthetically speaking, you can see how Disney is developing as Snow White approaches.